Transparency in Real Estate Crowdfunding: From the “Pre-Regulatory Era” to the Stringent European Standard

Transparency in Real Estate Crowdfunding: From the “Pre-Regulatory Era” to the Stringent European Standard

In recent weeks, the appearance in the press of various news stories about defaults and failed projects funded through crowdfunding platforms has, understandably, generated concern and uncertainty among investors.

To address what is happening with rigor and objectivity, it is essential to put the situation in context and review the regulatory evolution of the sector in Spain. What the market is experiencing today is not due to a flaw in the crowdequity or crowdlending model itself, but rather to the consequences of practices that originated before the current regulations were in place.

To better understand this, it is helpful to divide the sector’s evolution into three distinct regulatory phases:

1. The pre-regulatory era (prior to 2015): the origin of the conflict

Before April 2015, crowdfunding in Spain operated in a legal gray area. The pioneering platforms emerged during this pre-legislative period, an early phase in which structures were adopted that, over time, would shape the future of many projects:

Unsecured structures: Transactions were typically structured through unsecured loans or through direct equity investments in special purpose vehicles (SPVs) created specifically for each project.

Conflict of interest: At that time, there were no restrictions preventing platforms from acting simultaneously as fundraisers and as promoters or managers of the underlying project. This dual role created an obvious conflict of interest with respect to retail investors.

Absence of a first-lien mortgage: Investors assumed all the risks inherent in real estate development (obtaining permits, construction cost overruns, marketing risk, etc.) without the safety net provided by a mortgaged asset.

These practices prompted a warning from the National Securities Market Commission (CNMV), which led to the enactment of Spain’s first regulatory law. The legacy of those projects—structured under that initial, lax framework—is precisely the issue that continues to make headlines today.

2. Law 5/2015: The First Line of Defense

In April 2015, Law 5/2015 was enacted, marking the first regulatory milestone that defined the concept of Crowdfunding Platforms (PFP), placing them under the direct control and supervision of the CNMV.

This law introduced fundamental safeguards for the ecosystem:

Investment limits: designed to protect retail investors.

Express prohibition on conflicts of interest: platforms were prohibited from acting as promoters or financing entities linked to their own administrators.

Segregation of funds: A requirement was established to operate through regulated payment service providers, ensuring the complete segregation of investor funds from the platform’s balance sheet.

However, projects that were already underway under pre-2015 frameworks continued on their own momentum, carrying over the problems associated with their original corporate structures.

3. Regulation (EU) 2020/1503 (PSFP): The Standard for Institutional Maturity

Today, the ecosystem operates under the European Regulation on Crowdfunding Service Providers. This regulation has standardized the industry across the European Union and raised the standards for transparency, solvency, and corporate governance to levels comparable to those of traditional financial institutions.

Within this well-established framework, the industry has evolved. It has moved from unsecured loans to establishing crowdlending backed by first-lien mortgages—the model on which wecity structures virtually all of its opportunities.

The trend in Europe—and especially in Spain—is shifting toward this model because of its structural characteristics:

Investment through secured loans: The investor does not acquire an equity stake in the development company nor assume its purely corporate risk. The investor acts as a lender under predefined terms of return and is backed by a security interest.

First-lien mortgage: The loan granted by investors is secured by a mortgage deed executed before a notary public, registered in the Property Registry against the real estate or land, and always with a Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratio consistent with alternative financing standards.

Independent evaluation of the developer: The developer’s financial soundness is thoroughly audited, and the developer is required to demonstrate a proven track record and contribute its own capital to the project, thereby aligning its interests with those of the investors.

Conclusion: Learning from the Past to Build a Stronger Future

As is natural in any market, every investment carries associated risks, and it is essential that each investor assess the suitability of each transaction based on their profile. However, news about failed early-stage platforms should not be confused with the current reality. Equating the problems of “pre-ley” projects—conceived nearly a decade ago—with the rigor of today’s mortgage-backed crowdlending would be a misdiagnosis.

The sector has completed its transition. Today, it represents a transparent channel for financing and investment, strictly supervised at the European level and driven by risk mitigation through real mortgage guarantees. Demanding analytical rigor, reviewing the track record of compliance, and verifying the collateral structure are the best practices for the informed investor.

Based on this premise, at wecity we remain unwaveringly committed to transparency and regulatory compliance. For us, the measure of success lies not only in the volume of funding provided, but also in the amount of capital returned to our investors and in meeting the stipulated deadlines.

Antonio Mañas

CEO of wecity

Write a review about us

Your feedback on Trustpilot helps us to improve