Buy-to-rent vs. collaborative real estate investing: Which model fits your portfolio?

Buy-to-rent vs. collaborative real estate investing: Which model fits your portfolio?

The real estate sector has historically been the preferred investment for Spanish savers. For decades, the only way to generate income from real estate was through the traditional model: buying a home, renovating it, and finding a tenant.

However, the rise of alternative financing and real estate crowdlending has opened up a new avenue that democratizes access to the sector. It is no longer necessary to tie up large sums of capital or take on the role of a landlord to gain exposure to the real estate market.

If you’re debating whether to purchase a physical property to rent out or diversify your capital through participatory platforms, below we analyze the key differences between the two models.

1. Barrier to Entry and Initial Capital

  • Buying to Rent: Requires a significant upfront investment. In addition to contributing approximately 20% or 30% of the property’s value not covered by the mortgage, you must also factor in an additional 10% to 12% for taxes (property transfer tax or VAT), notary fees, registration fees, and any necessary renovations. This means tying up tens of thousands of euros in a single asset.
  • Real estate crowdlending: The barrier to entry is drastically reduced. Platforms like wecity allow users to build portfolios by investing in loans to developers starting with small amounts (for example, as little as €500 per project), making it easier to get started without having to deplete one’s capital.

2. Active Management vs. Passive Investing

  • Traditional Model (Owner-Occupied): Owning a property requires constant management. This includes everything from screening and selecting tenants to resolving property repairs, managing homeowners’ association assessments, paying property taxes, handling insurance, and attending homeowners’ association meetings. It is a model that requires time and dedication.
  • Participatory Model (Passive): Crowdlending is a purely financial and passive investment. The investor analyzes the project’s metrics (term, estimated return, collateral) and provides the capital. The platform handles the technical oversight of the transaction, and the Collateral Agent holds the mortgage registrations in trust. There are no calls about a broken boiler or rental management.

3. Risks: Tenants vs. Developers

Every investment carries inherent risks, but their nature varies depending on the model:

  • Risks of Buying to Rent: The landlord’s main concern is the risk of nonpayment by the tenant, followed by occupancy issues, vacancy periods (months without a tenant), or a decline in property values in the neighborhood.
  • Risks of crowdlending: The main risk is credit risk: that the project developer may experience financial difficulties, which could result in extensions of the initial term or defaults. Although transactions on wecity are backed by a first-lien mortgage and a prudent LTV ratio, a foreclosure proceeding is not without delays, and in any case, there is a risk of partial or total loss of principal.

4. Asset Diversification

  • Buy to Rent: Concentrate your risk. If you buy an apartment in a specific city, your success depends 100% on what happens on that street and with that tenant.
  • Crowdlending: Facilitates diversification. With the same capital you’d use for a down payment on an apartment, you can simultaneously finance dozens of projects in different cities, thereby spreading the risk and stabilizing your portfolio’s profile over the medium term.

These two strategies are not mutually exclusive. Many balanced investment portfolios combine direct ownership with the flexibility of alternative financing.

Check for risks: https://www.wecity.com/riesgos/

Write a review about us

Your feedback on Trustpilot helps us to improve